# Navigating the crossroads of quantum information and quantum foundations

A new book edited by Perimeter researcher Robert Spekkens and Visiting Fellow Giulio Chiribella highlights the information-theoretic approach to quantum foundations.

Now reading: Navigating the crossroads of quantum information and quantum foundations

Take a self-guided tour from quantum to cosmos!

A new book edited by Perimeter researcher Robert Spekkens and Visiting Fellow Giulio Chiribella highlights the information-theoretic approach to quantum foundations.

The field of quantum foundations is grappling with an unexpected problem: the challenge of scaling up.

For much of the history of quantum theory, most researchers considered the problem of understanding its foundations to be divorced from working out its applications. But 20 years ago, a shift started.

Quantum information theory came to the fore, and with it rose the idea that puzzling quantum phenomena, like entanglement and nonlocality, could hold the key for the next technological revolution. This led many to turn their attention back to the building blocks of quantum theory, to reconsider its foundations from the perspective of information theory.

A recent book co-edited by Perimeter Faculty member Robert Spekkens and Giulio Chiribella, a University of Hong Kong professor, Perimeter Visiting Fellow, and CIFAR-Azrieli Global Scholar, seeks to provide a high-level view of these efforts, and to serve as a roadmap to the most promising research directions.

Much of the research in the field has embraced a “pragmatic” approach, in which the laws of physics are characterized in terms of the fundamental limits to what can be known and achieved in experiments (as opposed to the “dynamicist” tradition, which does not factor in human agents or their purposes).

Using this method, theorists worked to establish the basic structures at the root of quantum information theory, to identify what powered such milestone applications as ultrafast quantum algorithms and quantum cryptography, and to isolate basic working principles that can be used to build new quantum protocols and applications.

Foil theories emerged as a useful tool in this effort. These theories describe the world as it could have been, were it not quantum mechanical. As the name suggests, such theories serve as “foils” to our current understanding of quantum mechanics: they provide a background against which the distinctive characteristics of quantum mechanics are thrown into relief.

As the field grew in size and popularity, there was a proliferation of new ideas and results. But this increased interest produced associated challenges. The diversity of approaches made it difficult to maintain a big picture of what was happening in the field, and the rise of specialist knowledge and language threatened to leave researchers out of touch with each other. These challenges were especially acute for newcomers to the field.

In 2011, the conference “Conceptual Foundations and Foils for Quantum Information Processing” at Perimeter aimed to cut through the haze. By bringing together the full breadth of researchers working on the topic, among them physicists, computer scientists, and mathematicians, the gathering underscored both the potential of the union of quantum information theory and quantum foundations, and the need for a global view of the field and its goals.

Spekkens and Chiribella were two organizers of that conference. Their book *Quantum Theory: Informational Foundations and Foils*, published by Springer, seeks both to showcase the breadth of the field and to tease out common themes.

The book includes 14 original contributions from leading experts in the field, among them a number written by Perimeter researchers and alumni, including Lucien Hardy, Christopher Fuchs, Markus Mueller, and Roger Colbeck.

The 29 contributing authors are not trying to overthrow quantum mechanics. On the contrary, they want to establish new and more efficient ways to reason about it.

Quantum theory is one of the pillars of modern science, thoroughly tested and highly successful. Understanding its core, they say, could lead to new ways to attack the most challenging problems of theoretical physics.

As Perimeter Faculty member Lucien Hardy wrote in his chapter, “It is in the finding of new physics that we can expect a real payoff of this program.”

Further Exploration

Related

For quantum gravity specialist and author Lee Smolin, Albert Einstein’s greatest strength didn’t lie in numbers.

*A Perimeter postdoctoral researcher and collaborators have created a practical quantum resource theory framework that has important implications for quantum computing, quantum communication, and more.*

Correlation does not imply causation – unless it’s quantum. That’s the message of surprising new work from Perimeter Institute and the Institute for Quantum Computing.

Perimeter Institute

Perimeter Institute is the world’s largest independent research hub devoted to theoretical physics. It was founded in 1999 to foster breakthroughs in the fundamental understanding of our universe, from the smallest particles to the entire cosmos. Perimeter is a not-for-profit, charitable organization devoted to fundamental research, training, and educational outreach. Be part of the equation.

Charitable Registration Number88981 4323 RR0001