Now reading: The curious case of Noether’s theorems

Enter to win the Ultimate Astronomy Experience in Hawaii!

The curious case of Noether’s theorems

When mathematician Yvette Kosmann-Schwarzbach set out to write about Emmy Noether’s now ubiquitous theorems, she was surprised to learn that Noether’s work did not always receive the recognition it deserved.

emmy noether

It is difficult to pick out which field of science has been most impacted by the theorems Emmy Noether formulated more than a century ago.

“In every field of science, they’re now absolutely fundamental,” says Yvette Kosmann-Schwarzbach, a mathematics professor at École Polytechnique in Paris. And yet, despite their broad applicability today and their initial recognition from other great contemporaries such as Hilbert, Klein, and Einstein, Noether’s theorems languished in obscurity for nearly 50 years after their publication in 1918.

Kosmann-Schwarzbach is helping to remedy that through her book The Noether Theorems: Invariance and Conservation Laws in the Twentieth Century, which delves not only into the mathematical and physical repercussions of Noether’s work, but into its historical context as well. She presented an overview of her findings at a colloquium at Perimeter in December 2018.

As a mathematician, Kosmann-Schwarzbach’s interest in Noether was first piqued in the late 1980s. While writing a short paper on Noether’s work, she learned that Noether had discovered not just one but two revolutionary theorems. Later, one of her students at École Polytechnique asked for an essay topic. She suggested he translate the article from Noether’s native German to Kosmann-Schwarzbach’s native French. Armed with a thorough translation, she could fully immerse herself in Noether’s work.

Noether’s results, she found, were brilliant and broadly applicable. In the simplest terms, she explains, Noether showed that any system with a symmetry[1] (and symmetries are rather ubiquitous in the natural world) also comes with an associated conserved quantity.

Why, then, did they fly under the radar for so long? “It’s a good question, and I think we don’t know,” replies Kosmann-Schwarzbach. “We find traces of propagation through the Soviet Union, which is kind of surprising, but we don’t know why her work was ignored for such a long time.” Perhaps, she muses, scientists in Western Europe and America didn’t care to read an article written in German. Some may have been averse to citing a woman or a Jewish person.

But a lack of recognition does not equate to a lack of importance. “What is interesting is that her work was actually rediscovered many times,” she says. “So it means the ideas and results are fundamental, they’re natural, they’re useful.”

Kosmann-Schwarzbach is hesitant to pin the temporary disappearance of the theorems on the fact that Noether was a woman. Certainly, she says, Noether’s life would have been different if she had been a man – for one thing, she would have faced fewer obstacles in obtaining paid positions. But she points out that Noether’s later work, in algebra, became quite widely known and celebrated.

“She gave a talk in the International Congress of Mathematicians [in 1932] – she was a plenary speaker – so I think she was not discriminated against as a woman in her work, in the impact of her work.”

Today, Kosmann-Schwarzbach says women scientists face much less discrimination and have far more opportunities. But there is always room for improvement: “There is a large potential of people who are not actually scientists, but who could be, and many of them are women.”


Watch Kosmann-Schwarzbach’s colloquium at Perimeter, “Emmy Noether’s two theorems, a hundred years later.”

[1] A feature of a system that remains unchanged under a transformation. Kosmann-Schwarzbach gives the example of rotating a tree about its axis (its trunk): a symmetrical tree would look the same as you spin it around.



For quantum gravity specialist and author Lee Smolin, Albert Einstein’s greatest strength didn’t lie in numbers.

/Nov 17, 2015

Get your fill of pi (videos) to celebrate Pi Day, including great short videos from Hank Green, James Grime, Veritasium and Physics Girl, Matt Parker, and (of course) Perimeter Institute.

/Mar 14, 2017

The worlds of theory and experiment collided at Perimeter Institute during a recent conference designed to spark breakthroughs in physics using small-scale experiments.

/Sep 28, 2017